The bottom line : privatizing the world
Review
How to talk about the dangers of the growing “commodification” of our planet without boring the audience ? The documentary screened today at Ecocinema, “The bottom line : privatizing the world” by Canadian director Carole Poliquin, undoubtedly lives up to that challenge.
According to her and the experts she interviews, we are trying to sell everything, to transform everything into a commodity, even what should belong to everyone, i.e. the common good. She breaks down her argumentation into seven chapters : the seven days it took God to create this world. But she puts a little twist in this biblical parable from the Genesis. She replaces the word God with the word “Businessman” and ends each chapter with the same line : “And The Businessman contemplated his work and thought it was good for his shareholders”. The repetition, while making fun of the vanity of man, acts as a comic relief counterbalancing a very serious enumeration of some alarming threats to mankind, like the commodification of water, ancestral knowledge, seeds, genes, healthcare, drugs, and the grip of international institutions on this new world order.
The style of the narration is very pleasing, but the convictions of the director tend to give a biased view on the subject, which is not really a bad point since we are talking about a documentary, not a debate. After all, politicians, scientists and the media are ubiquitous in real life to show us the other side of the coin and to convince us that market forces are also good for us.
Brief outline
Day One
The director shows us first a Canadian who sells fresh water to the highest bidder because he doesn’t see why he shouldn’t take advantage of this scarce resource just as Saudi Arabians sell their oil. The problem is that unlike oil there is no alternative to water as the voice-over puts it, and water should then belong to everyone. When the camera zooms out over a dry landscape at the end of the chapter we are made to think that the “commodification” of water is a bad thing for us.
Day Two
After the commodification of water, the director broaches the commodification of knowledge. In fact, some corporations patent processes to extract natural substances used by the beauty and healthcare industries. Yet these substances, like turmeric, have been used by generations of Indians for the very same reasons theses companies try to patent them. These communities know how to use them and the patents deprive them of a common knowledge built up over the ages, the very cement of their identity, as an Indian activist says in this chapter.
Day Three
But knowledge is not the only common good to be patented : Firms like Monsanto patent seeds and sue those who infringe their rights. Yet neither man nor a firm can grow a plant, as a farmer says. Just nature can. And nature is a common good.
Day Four
The human being doesn’t escape this patenting craze. Predictive medicine tries to patent genes to justify their investment in research, but the gene pool is the result of generations of evolution, and some scientists argue that for this reason it belongs to everybody.
Day Five
Access to healthcare too is limited by market forces. Millions of people in America don’t have health insurance and have no choice but to slowly die. Even some hospital managers feel they are rewarded for having the gut to refuse expensive treatments to the uninsured so they keep their bottom line in the black. The sight of a man who couldn’t afford to heal his gangrenous foot and decided to make a shoe on his own is a punch in the stomach.
Day Six
As the director shows it in her coverage of how AIDS is dealt with in Brazil, drugs are still very expensive as the pharmaceutical industry tries to make substantial returns on its investments. Yet drugs should be seen as a common good according to her since, as one of her interviewee says : “No return on investment justifies the death of a human being”.
Day Seven
Finally, to protect all these interests, The Businessman has created international trade rules, like NAFTA (North American Trade Agreement). This way he can make sure markets flow freely. And these rules are enforced by strong hands, those of heavily armed policemen as the final close up warns us.
Even though she never named them explicitly in her documentary, it seems that Carole Poliquin has bridged here a gap between History’s most famous Adams: Adam Smith, the economist who first theorized about the “invisible hand of the market”, and Adam, the first man created by God in the Genesis, the Bible book that serves as a framework to her illuminating story.
By Olivier Delesse (olivier@delesse.com)