<em>Elephant </em>- the Making Of
Gus Van Sant is one of the most courageous American directors working today.
He is never one to make a choice based upon convention or pressure from others;
he re-thinks and re-evaluates every step when making a film. In a time when
people are heralding the advent of digital cinema, Gus chose to film Elephant,
his latest effort, using a 35mm camera mounted on a traditional dolly. They
laid hundreds of feet of dolly tracks for the tracking shots, instead of using
a steadicam. Elephant was shot in the 1:33 aspect ratio long since
abandoned by most filmmakers worldwide. Elephant was cut on 35mm film
on a Kem editing table, which now seems like a fossil from another millennium.
The shooting of Elephant took place over a period of 20 days in an
abandoned high school in Portland Oregon. All of the students who appeared in
the film were real high school students who responded to an open casting call
in the Portland newspaper. Much of the dialogue was improvised, and many important
moments were created on the spot. For instance, the use of “Moonlight
Sonata” and “Fleur de lys” in the film were inspired by a
moment during lunchtime when one of the principal actors was practicing piano
on the set. Gus seized upon this immediately, added a scene of the boy playing
the piano into the film, and used these two pieces of music elsewhere in the
soundtrack.
After a month of editing I was summoned to Portland, Oregon, where Gus lives,
to create the sound design for the film. Gus rented a loft space over a brewery
where we set up an editing room/screening room/mixing theater, equipped with
film and video projection, 3 channel stereo monitoring, and a pro-tools editing
system. We had originally planned on creating the soundtrack on 35mm magnetic
film, but we couldn’t find a film recorder that we could rely upon, so
we switched to digital sound editing. We would have daily work sessions where
we would play through various reels of the film together, add sound effects,
correct problems in the dialogue and track in pieces of music and sound design.
We adjusted the levels of the different elements as we went along. This process
took place over a period of three weeks. Our end product was a pro-tools session,
which had all the soundtrack elements separated, but in essence a fully balanced
soundtrack.
Gus is very much against the use of background sounds and foley, which only
serve as filler with no artistic justification. For that reason, there is no
foley in the film. There are no artificial background ambiences such as bird
loops or walla or traffic. All background sounds and foley type sounds are ones
that were recorded originally as part of the original dialogue. There are, however,
many sound design moments which are explicit juxtapositions to the real sounds
one would expect to hear. In addition there is no looping in the soundtrack.
There are many instances where there are sounds I would have preferred to remove,
such as camera crew movement in the dolly shots, but Gus insisted on leaving
them in, adding to the spontaneity of the track.
All of the original dialogue was recorded using the MS stereo technique. The
on set recordist, Felix Andrews used a Schoeps hypercardioid and figure eight
capsule in parallel, which were then recorded onto 2 tracks of a DAT recorder.
He also used a second DAT recorder, which had a combination of wireless mics
from the various principal actors. We considered using the Nagra IV S, but Felix
convinced us that the weight of the recorder would be too cumbersome for him
to carry on his shoulder while following the camera crew through doorways and
down halls. We decoded the ms stereo into XY stereo in the course of the sound
editing. This gives a large stereo ambiant spread to the dialogue, which takes
advantage of the reverberant sound environment of the high school corridors.
We filled in the center channel with the wireless mics as needed.
We then took the Pro Tools sessions on a Firewire drive to Los Angeles where
we did the “final” mix at Wilshire Stages, over a period of 3 days.
Gus was very satisfied with what we had created in Portland, so we made only
minor modifications to the levels while in Los Angeles. On the 4th day we played
the mix in a screening room for the executives from HBO.
The reaction to the mix from the production executive and post-production supervisor of HBO was entirely negative. They were critical of what they felt was a lack of ambient sound and foley and long periods of silence. They didn’t understand certain sound design moments and considered these sound juxtapositions inappropriate. They criticized the sounds of crew movement and other “defects” they heard throughout the track. They declared the mix “technically unacceptable” and instructed us to start over again, from scratch. The mix was screened a week later for Colin Callender, the head of HBO films, and fortunately he agreed with Gus’ vision. What was ultimately presented in Cannes, was the mix we had originally made in Portland, with a few minor changes.
In all the creation of the soundtrack took place over a period of 6 weeks.
It was an effort that was spontaneous and creative. Gus created a film that
is sophisticated in its simplicity, in direct contrast to the commercial style
of filmmaking in America today. To have been recognized by the Cannes Film festival
is a truly great honor. “Vive la France.”
Leslie Shatz, Sound Designer, CST