Default Banner
Published by Editor
May 07, 2003
Established 1995 filmfestivals.com serves and documents the festival community, offering 92.000 articles of news, free blog profiles and functions to enable festival matchmaking with filmmakers.THE NEWSLETTER REACHES 198 000 FILM...

The State of Cinema Address at SFIFF

As delivered by Guest Programmer Michel Ciment at the 46th San Francisco International
Film Festival

If the title of this address sounds portentous, I will immediately downplay
it by stressing that my speech will express a very subjective viewpoint nourished
by my 40-year-old involvement in film criticism, festival attendance and of
course, reading experts and speaking with them. One of the striking features
of the state of cinema at any time is to see how the atlas of cinema is ever
changing. If we look at the map of the film world, we will see that the red
zone of intense creativity, the gray zones of intermittent presence and the
white zones of desertification have witnessed enormous variations if we look
at them in the 1960s, for instance, or today. Forty years ago Eastern European
countries, Italy, later Germany, offered a host of talented directors and some
of the major artists in the world: Tarkovsky, Wajda, Skolimowski, Makavejev,
Jancsó, Forman, Passer, Chytilova, Fellini, Antonioni, Visconti, Rosi, Pasolini,
Wenders, Herzog, Fassbinder and so many others. Today these countries have stopped
playing a significant role even if interesting films are still being produced
there.

On the map we see the appearance of new cinematographic territories, which
had attracted almost no attention 40 years ago such as Australia, Iran, Taiwan,
China, South Korea, or Hong Kong. The focus on them has replaced the one on
Quebec, Switzerland, Czechoslovakia, or Brazil. This is, to be sure, somewhat
unfair when the concentration of interest on some is at the expense of others.
We­-and particularly the critics­-should be on the lookout and pay attention
to whoever reveals a potential talent and not ignore it because his country
is not in fashion. More than ever it is the film and not the credits that deserve
attention. Recently and unexpectedly Diego Lerman, Lucrecia Martel, Pablo Trapero,
Carlos Sorín and others have revealed a new wave in Argentinian cinema. Without
excluding the factor of snobbism one must acknowledge that the shift in cinematographic
geopolitics corresponds to an observable reality. Directors like Abbas Kiarostami,
Im Kwon-Taek, Hou Hsiao-hsien, Edward Yang, Tsai Ming-liang, and Wong Kar Wai
have put Asia on the map and experiment fruitfully in film style.

There is something mysterious about the comatose state into which an art form
falls all of a sudden. Why did great painting disappear from Russia during four
centuries, and music from England (except for German immigrant composers) for
more than 200 years? One thing is sure for cinema: When a country has been under
a totalitarian regime and starts to breathe again, even within certain limits,
the artistic flowering is almost immediate. This is what happened in Eastern
Europe with the thaw in the Communist regime during the late 1950s and 1960s.
This is what happens today in Iran, South Korea, Taiwan and Argentina. The economic
factor plays also a major role. When the state stopped being involved in film
production as it occurred in Eastern Europe after 1990, the industry collapsed.

Only two countries have remained ever present-­artistically speaking--­in
the long history of cinema, not knowing any period of eclipse as it happened
to every other national industry. The American and the French cinema in fact
offer, as in so many other issues concerning our two countries, two almost opposite
points of view. The American cinema believes totally in the market, in the strength
of the liberal economy, and it has won over audiences all around the world thanks
sometimes due to the quality of its performers and directors, and always due
to its technical proficiency and recently its mastery of special effects. The
French cinema for better and for worse has maintained the idea of director as
an auteur (with the filmmaker’s right to final cut) and has tried to survive
the roller coaster of Hollywood films by protecting its industry. During the
last 45 years, a tax of little more than ten percent is being levied on every
ticket, and the money is being reinvested in French films. Thus a film is not
considered an industrial product but rather a part of the culture of the nation,
and as such, should not be submitted to the same economic laws that rule subsidies
for wheat or cars. This position-­called the cultural exception-­has been fought
against strongly by the American negotiators during the GAAT discussions, but
France, with the support of Germany, Italy and Spain, has been able to maintain
its singularity which explains partly the resistance of its cinema and its popularity
(30-40 percent of the French audience sees French films). It has thus been able
to produce or co-produce foreign directors who had difficulties being financed
exclusively by their own countries: David Lynch, Angelopoulos, Almodóvar, Kaurismaki,
Lars von Trier, Moretti, Wong Kar Wai, Tsai Ming Liang, Mike Leigh, Ken Loach,
Kiarostami, Pintilie and many central Asian or African directors.

Some countries like South Korea are following the French example to support
their most ambitious directors but other countries with a weaker spirit or less
possibility of resistance abandon any kind of protection under the pressures
of Hollywood interests and American diplomacy. We are here at the center of
the nature of cinema which is both an art and an industry, and which is nourished
by the tensions between the aesthetics and the economics. As the great art theoretician
Erwin Panofsky said, “There are two dangers for the artist: if he caters too
much to the audience, he may end up as a prostitute, but if he shuts himself
in an ivory tower, he will remain a virgin.” Which explains why there are too
many prostitutes in Hollywood and too many virgins along the Seine River.

The great lesson of the Hollywood of the past was its ability to produce films
that could appeal to a great variety of spectators. You could recommend a Hitchcock
or a Wilder, a Kazan or a Minnelli, to a farmer or to a professor, to a worker
or a doctor. As André Gide said watching a Chaplin movie, “What a thrill to
be in tune with the responses of a mass audience.” This was also true of Kurosawa,
Renoir, Visconti, Bergman or Lean. It seems that in the present state of the
cinema this is less and less true. There have been, of course, glorious exceptions,
particularly in Hollywood with Coppola, Scorsese, Kubrick or Altman, to name
but a few, but it seems that more and more a dichotomy prevails between great
cinema stylists with a limited audience­-the regulars of film festivals--and
mindless escapist movies with eye­boggling visuals, deafening sounds, and limited
substance.

The popular success of an original artist­-take for example, Pedro Almodóvar-­is
a comfort for those who hope that the best of cinema is not going to follow
the path of contemporary painting with its limited public and whose seal of
approval is applied by a small group of art dealers, critics and curators. If
the current state of Hollywood cinema worries me, I am not one of those who
bemoan American films as an opiate of the people and a vapid form of creation.
It has always been looked down upon­-even in its golden years­-and there are
enough talents today, more than anywhere in the world: Altman, Scorsese, Malick,
Spielberg, De Palma, Eastwood, Woody Allen, David Lynch, Spike Lee, Michael
Mann, Steven Soderbergh, the Coen brothers, Tim Burton, Tarantino, Oliver Stone,
Philip Kaufman, James Cameron, John Carpenter, Todd Solondz, Paul Thomas Anderson,
Larry Clark, John Sayles, Todd Haynes, Lodge Kerrigan, Milos Forman, to prove
its creativity. However, in the last two decades, a tendency has surfaced in
the industry to produce fragmentary sounds and images in a cumulative way and
in a manner very much akin to the world of videogames. The development of digital
imagery has made even more potent and possible this new relationship to space,
to time, to our body, a kind of derealization of the world, of a desensitization
of our feelings which make us less aware of the reality around us. Reality indeed
has become like a film. “Vietnam, the movie,” announced sardonically and prophetically
one character in Full Metal Jacket. This delicate balance between image
and idea, between our sense and our intellect which has been at the core of
the great masters of the cinema from Lang to Kubrick, from Hawks to Rossellini,
from Walsh to Resnais, from Dreyer to Mizoguchi, seems to have been tipped in
so many films aimed at a young audience­-which is the future­-in favor of a
flux of lights and colors without constraint, a cinema ruled exclusively by
pulse and energy without the slightest critical distance. In France Luc Besson¹s
films or Gaspar Noe’s Irreversible testify to this irresponsible trend.

Geoffrey King, in his book New Hollywood Cinema, has commented on this
impatience of the audience by measuring the duration of a shot in a classical
Hollywood film and in a contemporary one. Where it lasted 7.85 seconds in Spartacus,
it was only 3.36 seconds long in Gladiator, 8.72 seconds in The Fall
of the Roman Empire and 2.07 seconds in Armageddon.

Facing this lack of patience and themselves made impatient by the bombardment
of sound and image to which they are submitted as TV or cinema spectators, a
number of directors have reacted by a cinema of slowness, of contemplation,
as if they wanted to live again the sensuous experience of a moment revealed
in its authenticity. Angelopoulos in Greece, Nuri Bilge Ceylan in Turkey, de
Oliveira and Monteiro (who died a few weeks ago) in Portugal, Béla Tarr in Hungary,
Abbas Kiarostami in Iran, Tsai Ming-liang and Hou Hsiao-hsien in Taiwan, Philippe
Garrel and Bruno Dumont in France, Souleymane Cissé and Idrissa Ouedraogo in
Africa, Sharunas Bartas in the Baltic state, Aleksandr Sokurov in Russia, and
several directors in Central Asia have been proponents in recent years of a
resistance to the fetishism of technology. Kubrick, himself a master of technology,
has produced antidote films such as 2001: A Space Odyssey, Barry Lyndon
and Eyes Wide Shut with their provocative slowness.

If the Hollywood industry­-with its market studies, sneak previews, belief
in sequels and series­-sees the audience at its lowest common denominator as
its primary target (“If you run after the audience, you will only see its ass,”
Max Ophuls used to say), it would be wrong to believe that European cinema is
not prone to the same commercial self-censorship. Its financing is so closely
indebted to TV that the small screen imposes its criteria­-particularly for
primetime viewing­-to greenlight a script to be co-produced. It is probable
that some of the great European films of the 1960s: 8 ½; Pierrot le
Fou; Au Hasard, Balthazar; Viridiana; Persona;
The Servant; l’Avventura; Salvatore Giuliano; Last Year
at Marienbad; Shoot the Piano Player, would not have a chance to
obtain the approval of today’s TV committees. The result is that these aforementioned
films are still, 40 years later, bolder in their narrative structure, more complex
in their layers of meaning, more original visually than the best films of today
which, if at times excellent, seem tame and so rarely experimental, avoiding
controversial issues or stylistic challenges.

One of the ways to bypass the economic constraints and to regain a freedom
lost in more and more cumbersome productions has been the use of DV cameras
and of high definition. The Danish Dogma may have been a forerunner of this
tendency. However, its chart has always seemed to me more like a publicity stunt
than a real aesthetic manifesto not only because of the foolishness of some
of its rules (no static camera, no scenes set in the past, no artificial lighting)
but because if an artist can (and maybe) should set rules for himself, he can¹t
impose rules on others. Dogma nevertheless gave probably to some (Vinterberg)
the courage and the possibility to express themselves. DV on the whole will
allow a number of directors, particularly in the poorer parts of the world,
to direct again, or for the first time, to innovate at low cost or to deal with
urgent social and political issues. But again, one should not fetishize this
new technology whose limitations also exist. A true artist will always know
how to choose his tool according to his project. It is at the other end of the
chain that the digital technique has offered its most revolutionary instrument:
the DVD. It has already created a new relationship between the audience and
the film, a new way of teaching cinema and multiple possibilities of restoration
and rediscovery. The DVD has given a new life to the past of the cinema, and
consequently is changing its present state. It also raises some problems. With
its bonuses the uniqueness of the film is put in question. If a living director
decides to change the editing of one of his films (like Coppola with Apocalypse
Redux), he is of course permitted to do so. But to go back to an original
editing say La Ronde by Ophuls, A Star Is Born by Cukor, 2001:
A Space Odyssey by Kubrick, which had been modified subsequently by its
director, now dead, who is entitled to do so? Finally, the DVD may allow a director
to circulate within his own film and to impinge on its integrity. Thus Agnés
Varda has interviewed again, two years later, some of the people she had already
met for Les Glaneurs Et La Glaneuse. In the DVD of that film, every time
one of the protagonists appears you may click and his new intervention is inserted
in the flow of the film, which later resumes its course. In doing so, Varda
modifies her original film and elaborates a work in progress.

As I said earlier, the DVD opens new ways to the past without which there
is no future. One day Truffaut said, “We have to realize that we the directors,
we are soon going to be judged by critics who have never heard of Murnau.” Truffaut,
like the other New Wave directors, knew Murnau of course when he was a critic
and it helped him to be behind the camera. One becomes a writer by reading,
a musician by listening, an artist by looking at a painting, and a director
by watching films. May the choice of DVD be varied enough to allow us to go
back to the classics. The state of cinema will be better if in the future filmmakers
realize that in order to make a stylistic revolution, you need to know the tradition.
That is the lesson of Stravinsky, Joyce, Picasso and Eisenstein. It should be
the lesson of film schools.

There is maybe one last lesson to be learned from the present state of cinema.
It seems that the Lumière path (the recording of reality) and the Méliès path
(the animation process) have never been so trodden. With the development of
TV, thousands of channels are pouring out images of the world. This reality
effect has had its influence on fiction film, which centers more and more on
the details of everyday life. At the other end of the spectrum, we have the
Méliès syndrome of special effects and totally artificial worlds. The documentary
film (Lumière tradition) and the animation film (Méliès tradition), which for
a long time had their specific programs, are now integrated into mainstream
cinema and festival competition. Shrek won a prize in Cannes in 2001,
and a year later, so did Bowling for Columbine. Spirited Away
by Miyazaki won a Golden Bear last year in Berlin, and one of the highlights
of Cannes this year will be the screening of The Triplets of Belleville,
an animation feature from France.

What is most missing today is the fusion of Méliès and Lumière, the lesson
of the great masters of the past­-Renoir, Mizogushi, Fellini, Kubrick, Lang,
Bresson, Bergman, Buñuel, Tarkovsky, Welles and Ford­-who blended the artificial
and the real, creating through stylization a heightened realism, sometimes a
surrealism, always a synthetic vision of the world. This Promethean endeavor
was nourished by an intense curiosity for all the arts (painting, literature,
music, architecture) by a philosophical understanding of the world and an awareness
of the political and social issues of the day. It is not surprising perhaps
that a number of the emerging new talents that have set themselves those standards
(a Hou Hsiao-hsien, a Kiarostami) come from the East: They have a passion for
the media, a high cultural education, a freshness of approach and are anything
but blasé.