Default Banner
Published by Editor
Feb 09, 2003
Established 1995 filmfestivals.com serves and documents the festival community, offering 92.000 articles of news, free blog profiles and functions to enable festival matchmaking with filmmakers.THE NEWSLETTER REACHES 198 000 FILM...

The French Hitchcock : Claude Chabrol

He's known as the French Alfred Hitchcock, making films about bourgeois criminals
in provincial France, but what is exactly behind this façade? With his
latest film Flower of Evil in the official Berlin competition, Claude Chabrol
talks about his social and cinematic preferences in this exclusive Filmfestivals.com
interview.

You're known as a French master of the thriller genre. What is it that you
find attractive in this particular genre?



I think it is a genre that allows one to deal with all kinds of subjects in
climactic circumstances. It's either "I kill you", "I don't kill
you", "I steal from you", "I retaliate", "I manipulate
others"... These are strong, powerful situations. At the same time, since
thriller is a genre, it has a certain set of rules which you have to abide by,
and this calls for some modesty, self-effacement. I think it is wonderful to
be able to deal with all kinds of subjects, and deal with them with modesty!
I think this is a must!

Can your cinema be labeled "social cinema"?



I think a social film is a film that deals with the underdog classes, the have-nots.
It's interesting to make such films, to denounce things, but in a sense, all
you can ever do is show things. I think it is funnier to make social films the
other way round (smiles), that is to say dealing with the haves! It's more significant.
Rather than showing, I think it's more interesting to dismantle things. And
to do that, you have to deal with the summit; I think factory managers are more
interesting than workers. Indeed, workers are humanly more interesting, but
dealing with managers is more relevant to the way factories work. This being
said, I think that I also derive great pleasure from working in provincial France
and making bourgeois people bite the dust! (laughs)

Most bourgeois people in your films are criminals. Why is that?



Well, first of all, there are different types of crimes. There are professional
crimes, which I'm less interested in. There are 'poor people crimes', and 'rich
people crimes'. 'Rich people crimes' are often driven by financial greed, and
I don't find that very interesting either. I like paradox, I like "rich
people" crimes driven by sex. I think it's very funny when passion creeps
into a highly-civilized environment and smashes it to smithereens. At the same
time, I'm not against a bourgeois type of society. But this kind of society
implies forms of petty-mindedness which indeed have to be fought off.

Do you find it interesting to steer away from the kind of films people usually
expect from you?



Well, I hate things that are too clear-cut, unequivocal. From the films I've
made about socially modest people, the one I like best is The Story of Women.
Marie Latour, the main character is indeed not innocent, she's not Joan of Arc,
but what she does, she does for noble reasons, to feed her children. That's
how it all begins, and then the principle of luxury seeps into her and gives
her broader tastes that are less justifiable. She becomes a disreputable person
and only becomes herself again because she ends up a martyr in the hands of
people that are far more disreputable than she ever was.

For the Cognac Film Festival in 2001, you were offered carte blanche to
choose a special 6-film program in which you included one film by Fritz Lang
but none by Hitchcock. Does it mean you feel a greater kinship with Lang?



I feel a kinship with both. Yet, I think my way of directing is more akin to
that of Lang. But I'm just not in the same league as them.

What do you like most about Lang? The apparent simplicity of his mise-en-scène?




Yes, I like the kind of terrible precision of his mise-en-scène, which
allows him to get powerful effects out of seemingly nothing. It's wonderful
the way he creates frightening little noises, unsettling sound and visual disruptions.
He makes the opening of a door more formidable than a clatter of sounds.

Do you visualize a whole film in your head when you're writing the script?



Well, I can't start working on a film unless I have very precise notions of
it in my head. I can read a script and perceive all the visual elements in it.
I know that each comma corresponds to a visual element. Yet, I am conscious
that I will have to face all kinds of problems once the shooting begins. Maybe
the settings will turn out to be different from the ones I expected. So if I
can't get precisely what I wanted, I try to get something equivalent. But you
have to be very clear-sighted about your films to know how to get at least the
equivalent.

Did you ever feel constrained by the medium budget range of your films?



Well, I wouldn't like to have less money, but more... I think you have to be
careful with bigger budgets. Something odd happened to me ten years ago. I was
shooting a film in Germany [Dr M], it was a co-production, and there
were just too many people on the set! When I asked for 30 extras, I got 50.
There were too many assistant directors. I was wondering what was going on;
in fact, it was the production manager who tried to take the film away from
the producer by spending as much money as possible in the first weeks of shooting!

So I think you have be careful with big budgets. I think it's better to have
just the amount you need. On the other hand, you have to have enough shooting
time. That's why I stay away from television now. Shooting schedules for television
have become incredible, something like 20 days! Directors are barely left enough
time to think about what they're actually doing! There's no way you can do what
is called 'Art' under such circumstances! (laughs)

You've often worked with the same actors throughout your career, yet offering
them different roles each time. Is it important for you to provide actors with
variety?



I have a deep distrust of actors who always play the same roles. When I pick
the same actors, it means they've not only been good, I also have had no communication
problem with them. So when I happen to find people who speak the same language,
I am gladly willing to work with them again. But sometimes I see a guy or a
girl in a show, in a play, and I say to myself: "He or she's gonna be right
for the part!" Also, I have a great casting director. She's a queen. She's
the one who's gonna find the right person for a part.

Do you and Isabelle Huppert speak the same language?



Isabelle and I are so much on the same wavelength that our collaboration has
become something of a game. We can just keep quiet and understand each other
perfectly. She's a very smart woman and just doesn't need much direction. For
Nightcap, the only thing I told her was: 'Would you like to play a totally
perverted woman?' So she said: 'Yes, yes, yes, yes.' And then I added: "And
what's more, she's Swiss!" And then she just said: "Oh, wonderful!"
She understood what I meant!

For Flower of Evil, you decided to cast Nathalie Baye and Suzanne
Flon...

I was certain that Suzanne Flon would bring some kind of magic to the role
of this mythical "matriarch". She has this knack for playing characters
in a seemingly benign way, as if she were a little mouse, but she can also roar
like a lion. Concerning Nathalie Baye, I gave her very few acting tips. Rather,
I wanted her to get her inspiration from existing politicians, and flesh her
character out through the clothing and certain behavioural habits.

Why did you shoot the film near Bordeaux?

I had already shot Dr. Popaul near Bordeaux. I chose to shoot this film
in the same area because I wanted to tell the story of a family that perpetuates
itself carefully, and that is something quite common there. Furthermore, I wanted
the character of Tante Line's father, Pierre Charpin, to bring memories of a
local dignitary who has been the talk of the town lately. I must say we really
enjoyed filming all those fake campaigning politicians. They had to look duly
cliché and dull. In this milieu, when one says he's a left-wing, chances
are that he is also a right-winger!

Yannis Polinacci & Robin Gatto