Default Banner
Published by Editor
Sep 06, 2003
Established 1995 filmfestivals.com serves and documents the festival community, offering 92.000 articles of news, free blog profiles and functions to enable festival matchmaking with filmmakers.THE NEWSLETTER REACHES 198 000 FILM...

More cheers than jeers at Mostra 60

The 60th Mostra International Venice Film Festival

After the downer that was Cannes, most critics were looking forward to being given a lift by Venice. On paper, the programme was promising and, on the whole, it did not disappoint. However, during the Festival, there was some grumbling that Venice had become too commercial and star-oriented, with the accent on Hollywood. Sure enough Woody Allen, Johnny Depp, Nicolas Cage, George Clooney, Bill Murray, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Tim Robbins and Emma Thompson, turned up to wave to the fans. There were also fears that the main jury would go for the more popular films, and there were rumours that they were under pressure to award the Golden Lion to Goodmorning, Night (Buonogiorno, Notte) by Marco Bellocchio because of its political content (the last days of Aldo Moro), and because Italy needed a winning film.
But, in the end, all these fears and complaints were unjustified given the general quality of the films in the various sections and that the best film in the official competition, by consensus, was rewarded with the top prize. This was The Return, an impressive first feature by Andrej Zvjagintsev, which was astutely stolen from the competition in Locarno at the last moment by Moritz de Hadeln. An intense and haunting film set in a remote area of Russia, where a martinet father, returning after many years away (we never know where), goes on a fishing trip with his two teenage sons. The film was given extra poignancy in hindsight when it was learned that the 15-year-old actor who played the older brother drowned in the lake where the film was made soon after shooting.
There were a few other dramas during the Festival. Babak Payami’s Silence Between Two Thoughts, a powerful allegory of dictatorship, was confiscated by the Iranian authorities. Therefore, it was shown in an inferior quality video print, though the film’s excellence shone through. There was also talk that Fox Searchlight was demanding various cuts in Bernardo Bertolucci’s The Dreamers, before its release in the USA. These would include close-ups of both male and female genitalia and a shortening of a prolonged masturbation scene. But the beautifully shot and played film – mostly interiors – is not lurid, though there is a certain voyeuristic aspect to it. Cinephilia as much as sex is part of the texture of the film, which is rather shallow about Paris in May ’68, the background to a youthful ménage á trois.
Every festival has its scandals and Venice was no exception. People were leaving in droves during Bruno Dumont’s 29 Palms and, those that stayed, greeted it with boos. Dumont, whose first two films, La Vie de Jésus and L’Humanité, were very impressive, has fallen into the trap of thinking it’s enough for a foreign director to go the USA and film motels, supermarkets, gas stations and endless roads and present it as an exotic country. The cinematography is superb, but the almost incomprehensible leads and the unintentionally risible sex, damage its credibility.
Another disappointment was Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu’s 21 Grams, which takes a soap opera drama and breaks up the narrative into flashbacks, flash-forwards and flash-ins, in the belief that the story would be more interesting that way. There is a certain fascination for the first 30 minutes in trying to understand what is happening and who is who, but finally the experience is like watching a 2-hour trailer.
Disappointing, too, was the Coen Brothers’ Intolerable Cruelty, their least personal, least referential and most commercial movie. But it was more fun than Michael Winterbottom’s silly sci-fi romance, Code 46, and Christopher Hampton’s Imagining Argentina, a lurid and ugly insult to the ‘disappeared’. But enough bad news, or rather, news of the bad.
The best mainstream movie was Sofia Coppola’s Lost In Translation, starring a wonderfully forlorn Bill Murray, lonely and adrift in Tokyo. There is a certain uncomfortable stereotyping of the Japanese, but neither are the Americans spared. Yet, it is an affectionate portrait and brilliantly escapes the clichés of romantic comedy.
Other films that stood out were Goutam Ghose’s In The Forest… Again, which takes the same characters and actors from Satyajit Ray’s Days and Nights in the Forest back to the location of the first film over 30 years later; Srdjan Karanovic’s Loving Glances, which deals in a comic-tragic fashion with the problems of a young refugee in Belgrade; and Travellers and Magicians, a charming and seemingly simple film from Bhutan, directed by Khyentse Norbu, who is a Buddhist monk. It was this variety of worthwhile films from all over the world that made this year’s Venice particularly rewarding.

Ronald Bergan