How Riri Riza Escaped from Escapist Cinema
After making the home hit Sherina's Adventure, a musical for families
that was seen by over 1.5 million people in Indonesia, emerging director Riri
Riza chose to steer away from commercial film and go back to his underground
adventures with the self-produced and DV-filmed Eliana, Eliana, dealing
with the condition of women in a society caught between tradition and modernity.
He is part of the "I Cinema" manifesto generation of filmmakers trying
to create innovative cinema in post-Suharto Indonesia. Filmfestivals.com met
Riri Riza at the 2003 Deauville Asian Film Festival, where the film won the
award for Best Female Performance.
You started your career as a filmmaker under the Suharto regime, with many
difficulties in terms of creative freedom. Still, you managed to make Kuldesak
over a three-year period of production, with partners such as Nan Achnas (Whispering
Sands). Could you talk about how it was difficult to make films back then,
and how things started to change after the fall of the Suharto regime?
Indonesian filmmaking has a long history, actually. We used to have some sort
of a big film industry, until ten or fifteen years ago. The scale back then
was 100 to 150 films produced yearly. But as you know, there was a time when
there were fairly strong restrictions against filmmaking. So film was nurtured
in quantity, but as regards the kind of cinema that was made, it was mostly
escapist cinema. There was no such thing as critical, good quality, artistic
films. The government tried very hard to push cinema towards one direction only,
the propaganda of escapist cinema. So I grew up and graduated from film school
at the peak of that era. And the government started to see that there was an
underground generation of young filmmakers trying to escape from that tradition.
We, as filmmakers at that time, felt that there was no cinema representing
the spirit of the youth. So me and four of my friends started to make films
that wanted to break the routine of Indonesian cinema. The way we did it was
basically underground, because at that time, during the Suharto era, every time
you made a film, you had to submit the script to the government bodies, in order
to get their approval, and then maybe you had a shooting permit. So basically,
at that time, we never had a shooting permit, we would shoot behind walls and,
you know, manage things in a guerilla way!
The first film was Kuldesak, directed together with four other young
directors. And now, these four friends have become directors in their own right
since the fall of the Suharto regime. There's for instance Nan Achnas, the director
of Whispering Sands, a film that was also shown at the Deauville Asian
Film Festival. And I have already made my second and third film now, with Mira
Lesmana, who has always been my producer. Rizal Matovani, another of my friends,
made Jelangkung, a very successful commercial horror film. And you know,
now, things are basically going OK. We don't have to submit our scripts anymore.
We have to face different kinds of challenges now...
Could you tell us about the "I manifesto", according to which
13 young directors, including yourself, pledged to make 13 innovative films?
After Kuldesak, some friends and I were thinking about how to further
develop our local cinema's identity. Basically, now, we don't have that many
restrictions, but Indonesia is now entering a global open world and we have
to compete with cinema from all over the world. So we have to develop our own
language. The "I Manifesto" is basically about trying to develop many
different possibilities in Indonesian cinema. And Eliana, Eliana was
one of them. With this manifesto, I am trying to create cinema with freedom,
I am trying to democratize the medium and return to the roots of storytelling
in a basic form. (Smiles)
We don't think about technology, we try to make films with the accessibility
that we have, which is, you know, consumer product cameras, DV cameras... In
Eliana, Eliana I had the opportunity to work with a very professional,
established theatre actress. The actors gave me great performances, and I think
I gave them a good story to feed on. We basically shot the film in a very simple
way. And that is the tendency of the "I cinema" manifesto. Trying
to explore the language, the medium, trying to look for a new identity, whatever
it is. Because the Indonesian identity is hard to define nowadays. There is
a lot of confusion and questions in it. So that's what we are trying to explore
with the "I Cinema" manifesto.
And you are taking risks by doing so. Before Eliana, Eliana, you
made Sherina's Adventure, a very successful musical. And then afterwards,
you chose to make this DV film in 14 days, which is a film that might not click
with the mainstream audience...
I think it's a quest for filmmakers to always go for something new. I entered
a very interesting area after the success of the film you are talking about.
Sherina's Adventure was a musical for families. It was seen by over 1.5
million people. It was a record since, before, successful films had an attendance
of around 200,000 people. So it was an amazing success. But after such a success,
people tend to ask from you the same thing, the same formulae, and that's a
great boredom for filmmakers. So my strategy was to try and make something new,
and Eliana, Eliana is a film that, in a way, released me from the burden
of always having to make successful films. It might seem to appear like a strange
decision, but I have often seen this kind of move from the directors that I
admire.
Could you tell us more about the inception of Eliana, Eliana?
It's a film about how I see life in Indonesia today, especially the gap between
generations, the difficulties for generations to understand one another. What
we have now since the reform of the Suharto regime is people blaming each other
for what happened. People started to blame each other for all the mistakes that
happened in Indonesian history over the past 30 years. The younger generations
blamed the older generations and the other way round. So I think it's very important
to make films about this situation, and Eliana, Eliana is a reflection
of this.
I always admired strong women, basically. I think women are fragile in every
society, especially in my society, my culture. In West Sumatra, where my wife's
roots lie, women have always been very strong, very independent. But on the
other hand, they are part of the Muslim community, where women always have to
obey their husbands. So that kind of contradiction is very interesting, and
I started to explore this and found the idea of the meeting between two generations.
The mother stems from Padang, while the runaway daughter lives in Jakarta.
Could you tell me about the main cultural differences between the two cities
and the two areas?
Indonesia is interestingly complex. Traditions in this country differ with
every province. People speak different languages and have different ways of
life. In you live in Padang, in West Sumatra, you are approximately two hours
from Jakarta by plane. It's a different island, with different traditions. But
the younger generations now look towards higher levels of life with modernity
as their reference. So Eliana, Eliana is basically about a young woman
who tries to release herself from traditions, while the mother believes in the
benefits of good old traditions. That's the set-up of the story: two women from
different generations, with different opinions about life, and how they meet
one night.
So your wife, like the mother in the film, is actually from West Sumatra?
(Smiles) Yes. And she's from Padang, actually. (Laughs) My wife comes from
the kind of family depicted in Eliana, Eliana. A very big family! Her
mother is one of the sources of inspiration for the mother in Eliana, Eliana.
A lot of her aunts live in the same area, with the same life style. In some
way, they all wanted to break away from the traditions, but eventually all returned
to traditions and tried to get their daughters to abide by traditions. So all
these women live in a kind of circle, which is very interesting.
Tell us more now about the shooting of Eliana, Eliana, the choice
of DV, the very short schedule, mostly night...
The concept of how to shoot the film started with my wish to explore new languages
in cinema. One, we wanted to film a story we utterly believed in, and not many
people believed in me when I pitched the concept of Eliana, Eliana. So
basically, we had to finance the film ourselves and shoot it the way we could
afford it. So in fact, I had already written the script for Eliana, Eliana
with 14 days of shoot in mind. So it all started in the writing, and then we
succeeded in filming in 14 days, all on location, with one single camera, always
on the move and hand-held. We used basically the lighting we had on location,
with just a little bit of added light. I did a lot of rehearsals with my actresses
prior to the shooting. They were very good, very dedicated. Their commitment
was really part of what made that kind of film possible.
You seem to always be surrounded by women, in your private life as well
as in your professional life, with your previous partners, like Nan Achnas,
your co-producer, who is also a woman. Are you going to champion the cause of
women in Indonesia?
(Laughs) I think it's very important to have women in cinema. Filmmaking is
a crazy world, and if you are on your own as a man, it's even crazier. So I
work a lot with women. I enjoy working with them, because there is such a different
aura when they are around. And it's been years now since I have told stories
that involve strong female characters. Even my first film was about a child
female prodigy. In my society, women are very important though they are also
very fragile. This is very interesting to me.
There is also a reference to Indian movie star Amitab Bachchan in your film.
Why is that?
My mother and father always went to see his films when I was a child. They
were big fans. I could not stand it at times, but it was like that. He is indeed
a legend. And it's amazing for me to see that the Deauville Asian Film Festival
is honoring him this year. What a coincidence! If I get a chance to meet him,
I'll have him sign an autograph! (Laughs)
Robin Gatto