<i>Bus 174</i> from Director Jose Padilha
Produced by director José Padilha and Marcos Prado, Bus 174 is
a reflection on the endemic problem of street kids, urban decay, and violence
in Brazil. The film focuses on one episode - the June 12, 2000 hijacking of
a passenger bus in the fashionable south side of Rio de Janeiro. Bus 174
is screening at Sundance as one of the ten documentaries selected to be
part of the new World Cinema Documentary program. It previously won both the
Public Award for Best Documentary and the FIPRESCI Critics Award for Best Brazilian
Film of the Year at the Rio de Janeiro International Film Festival 2002. It
also won The International Critics Award for Best Documentary at the Sao Paulo
International Film Festival 2002.
What prompted you to make this film?
I was at the gym and saw on the television that this hijacking was taking place,
right where I live. All the routes were closed off so I stayed at the gym, watching.
One of the things with me was the way it was broadcast live for everybody to
see…Should you broadcast a hijack that could end in tragedy at any second?
Should that be on TV at 3pm? I mean kids can see that. So it was not only the
hijack, but how the media dealt with it...And the real life story proves that
the media changed the behavior of the hijacker, of the police…it became
sort of a show…
In a certain sense it was like a big theatre, like Brazil was rehearsing, playing
itself on television. It struck me that the television treated it like a real
live show. It dealt with the police and explained away Sandro…it said there's
this crazy guy who hijacked the bus and this was to explain everything about
him… to me, this was preposterous, because this guy has a story and that
story is what counts.
Did how you look at the situation change you at all during or after you
made the film?
It changed me, certainly, in the way that I will never look at a street kid
the way I did before. When I am stopped at a streetlight, even if I don't have
any money I will open the window and talk to them, because it makes a difference
if you acknowledge that they are there….and to me the prisons…the
Brazilian prisons are something I cannot forget. It is disgusting… it is
not acceptable, I don't care what the crime is…you have 20 people living
on top of each other, it is not acceptable, it is simply preposterous.
The opening struck me as really effective, showing us the high image of
Rio and its beauty and then we finally enter the streets of Rio, we find it
is not as pretty. Was that your intention?
That's how it works for a foreign audience…I had many intentions with
that opening shot…I went to many areas, a way to visually generalize the
situation. The first shot in particular, it is easy for many Brazilians to understand-
that is the bus route…I followed the bus route…and when the camera
tilts up, it tilts up exactly where the bus was hijacked and stopped….what
that shot shows is Brazil, the poverty is really close to the rich people…and
that to me it is the source of all this conflict and violence.
Is one of the reasons you kept the title simple to reflect that it could
have been any bus in Brazil?
Yes, you are exactly right. And bus in Portuguese is 'ônibus' and ônibus
means equal for all…one of the things the opening shot does is to show
how that bus picks up passengers from poor areas and it goes past the most fancy
university in Rio and it goes past fancy neighborhoods in Rio and all these
people take the same bus…so it could be anyone…I take that bus.
You mentioned at the screening how difficult it was to shoot the scenes
in the crowded prisons, yet you made them appear so artful?
What I did was this: I had two choices, either I would blur everyone's face,
a legal constraint, or I would do some effects that wouldn't let people recognize
who was there...I put everything in black and white first, then I revered, everything
that was white became black, everything that was black became white, that effect
is the opposite of society in a sense to me. Then I shaded it to make it the
same color of the other jail.
Although it seems you could, you don't point the finger or blame one individual
for what went wrong during the film. Why?
I wanted my film to talk about everybody's mistakes…I had a list of stuff
that I didn't want to do during the editing and I followed that as much as I
could and one of them was not to point a finger at anybody, because I don't
think it is anybody's fault…things have to change structurally. If you
replace one police officer with another, the same thing would have happened.
You showed the former hostages, the live video of the hijacking to elicit
more genuine response and refresh their memories of that day. Were there times
when this became emotionally difficult or they asked you to stop?
No, because what I did was rent a studio and project the film, and told them
this is like a home movie and you take the remote control and stop it…they
could do anything they wanted.. I invited them to be part of an experiment with
me…to join me in the project.
Do you know what your next film is going to be about?
I am shooting a documentary about hunger. I am telling the story of a community
of people who have to deal with hunger on a daily basis…and really about
the choices they have to make, about the politics of hunger.
Do you plan to return to writing narratives or will you continue making
documentaries?
I don't think a documentary director is close to a theatrical fiction director
in any way because a documentary director when he is shooting a film is searching
for a story while doing this and a fiction filmmaker already knows what his
story is about when he starts to shoot. I think that a documentary filmmaker
is closer to a screenwriter in that way. So if I were to direct a fiction feature,
I'd probably end up writing the screenplay, and I don't know how that would
turn out.
Rachel Markus